California lawmakers expressed strong disappointment after Kaiser Permanente declined to participate in an informational hearing regarding its mental health services. The hearing, organized by the Assembly health committee, aimed to discuss the company’s compliance with state mental health laws and its recent $200 million settlement for violations.
Assemblymember Mia Bonta, chairing the hearing, highlighted her frustration as she read from a letter sent by Kaiser officials. The letter explained the company’s absence, citing concerns about the potential influence of the National Union of Healthcare Workers, which recently reached a tentative agreement with Kaiser for a new contract affecting 2,400 employees in Southern California.
Bonta, a Democrat representing Oakland, criticized Kaiser’s decision to send only a letter instead of representatives. “I’m supremely disappointed,” she stated. “We have an opportunity to engage in conversation with them, and this response is unacceptable.”
Over 9 million Californians are insured by Kaiser, making it the largest health plan in the state. Recent scrutiny has revealed issues within its mental health services, including a history of violations. In 2014, regulators imposed a $4 million fine on Kaiser for delaying patient access to care. The 2023 settlement included a $50 million penalty and required an additional $150 million investment in improving mental health services.
During the hearing, various stakeholders, including union representatives and patients, voiced concerns about ongoing challenges within Kaiser’s behavioral health system. Assemblymember Celeste Rodriguez, also a Kaiser patient, noted the significance of Kaiser’s absence, stating, “Their absence speaks volumes.”
Union leaders underscored persistent issues like chronic understaffing in mental health departments. Sophia Mendoza, president of the National Union of Healthcare Workers, remarked, “Patients report that while they receive excellent care for physical issues, they struggle to access help for mental health conditions like depression and anxiety.”
Kaiser’s spokesperson defended the company, stating that it has invested over $1 billion in enhancing mental health care since 2020 and employs more than 30,000 staff for these services. The company claims to offer greater access and choice than ever before and complies with state access requirements.
Despite these assertions, the testimony from the hearing painted a different picture, highlighting the ongoing challenges faced by patients seeking mental health care. The absence of Kaiser representatives at a hearing meant to address these issues further fueled concerns about the company’s commitment to transparency and accountability in its mental health services.
Spanish 
English 
French 
German 
Russian 
Belarusian 
Ukrainian